Cooking Issues

The International Culinary Center's Tech 'N Stuff Blog

Cooking Issues header image 2

Microwave Vacuum Dehydration: failed experiment

June 30th, 2009 · 6 Comments · Vacuum Dehydration

posted by Dave Arnold

In response to a rotovap post, Asbel Reyes wrote:

What’s your thoughts on marrying a microwave, a superfreezer, a cold trap, and vacuum for instant freeze drying?

Well, I haven’t tried that exactly; but I have dabbled with microwave vacuum dehydration (MVD). In October 2006, Johnny Iuzzini and I were working on a demo for PastryScoop and I wanted to try something new. I had heard of a technique for quickly dehydrating grapes by placing them under a vacuum (which lowers the boiling point of water), and microwaving them to boil off that water at a low temperature. Microwaves are perfect for this because they can heat the inside of a material (as long it’s small, like a grape). As soon as the water is gone from one part of the grape, that part stops absorbing microwaves—it doesn’t heat up and burn (This is why the nuke is also great for drying bread for bread crumbs). Even better, because the water is constantly boiling out, the grapes don’t shrivel up and lose their structure. From a logistical point of view, the cold traps and vacuum pumps don’t need to be as good as a freeze dryer. Awesome… in theory.

Modified linear-power microwave with vacuum chamber

Modified linear-power microwave with vacuum chamber

The first hurdle to jump was getting the right microwave. Most microwaves don’t actually change the amount of power they are putting out when you switch them from low to high, they just turn on for a couple of seconds, then off for a couple of seconds. No good for our purposes. They make linear power microwaves with real power selection but they are expensive. No dice.  What sucks is you can’t just put a dimmer switch on the transformer that goes to the microwave’s magnetron because it controls both the magnetron heater wire and the high voltage input. Dang. Solution: I bought two microwaves from Craig’s List for 20 bucks, ripped them apart, took the transformer from one and bolted it in the other with a dimmer switch. Whammo, linear power. Yes, it is dangerous. No, I won’t tell you how to do it.

Next I needed a vacuum chamber. I took a food saver jar and made a polycarbonate lid with a silicone rubber seal. I put two holes in the top, one for the vacuum hose, and one for a thermocouple. Next I drilled two holes in the microwave interior less than 1/4 in diameter, and jammed a tube connector in one and a thermocouple wire through the other. The thermocouple was to measure the temperature of the food so I could get the power just right. Holes that size won’t leak microwaves if properly baffled with metal. I checked with a microwave leak detector.

Interior of the vacuum microwave with chunks of orange

Interior of the vacuum microwave with chunks of orange

Next I took the vacuum hose out of the microwave and ran it through my handy-dandy cold-trap (remember this from the ghettovap?). After the cold-trap, the line went into the vacuum pump from an old, broken commercial vacuum-packer Johnny had brought to The FCI to play with. I fired up the rig with nothing in it and the whole damn thing worked, no arcing, no problem. Done. Yeah, right.

Cold-trap with chiller

Cold-trap with chiller

I put chunks of orange in my vacuum chamber that were sized just right for full microwave penetration, put the thermocouple in one of the chunks, sealed the chamber, started the vacuum, and turned on the microwave. What I hadn’t thought of was that under partial vacuum, microwave ovens really, really want to make balls of plasma. Giant balls of fire kept shooting off the thermocouple. So I ripped out the thermocouple. Then I kept on getting balls of fire coming off my oranges. I couldn’t seem to stop the whole thing from become a charred, stinking mess. The plasma kept burning through my vacuum chamber, etc. etc. FAIL. I tried six times over the course of three days and didn’t even think to get decent pictures of the plasma. I was too depressed.

To Asbel’s point. I didn’t try to freeze the product first (you aren’t supposed to for MVD). Maybe that would work. For more info on microwave plasma see here. For more on MVD see here.

Lastly, I definitely recommend that you don’t put light bulbs, CDs, whole raw in-shell eggs, or anything of that nature in your microwave.

Tags: ·

6 Comments so far ↓

  • myhbar

    I did a small scale version of the plasma experiment with grapes and it was quite fun (video here: http://myhbar.wordpress.com/2009/06/18/make-your-own-plasma/) but of course not as elaborated as this. A friend of mine always wanted to have an “antimicrowave” to cool down your soup just a bit when it is too hot, so please keep working on this I’m sure it would sell really well :).

  • microwaveguru

    Microwave vacuum drying of fruits & vegetables had been done satisfactorily for years by a company in France that is now defunct. There are indications that it may be coming back. However, that is much less vacuum than freeze drying. Millions of dollars have been spent trying to accomplish microwave-freeze drying, all of which failed. The stumbling block is that at very reduced pressure the arcing capacity increases dramatically, so you end up with a plasma. As to your use of a dimmer switch – it really can’t work well because the reduction of output power with voltage is not linear – so you may suddenly go from 1000 watts to 200 watts within a few volts. Finally, you do need very low microwave power in order to vacuum dry.

    • Dave A

      As you say, the output dropped off precipitously as the dimmer switch was turned down. I did seem to get ok regulation near the top based simply on time-to-boil-water tests, but I have no idea how much actual power it was putting out. Linear was clearly not the right word (it was a marketing term, I think for Pasnasonic). I should have said adjustable. I couldn’t get past the arcing problem under vacuum. BTW, what do you do with microwaves? do you have any good tricks or ideas?

  • Roberto N.

    My microwave is a plasma junkie. It will start shooting off even when supposedly safe stuff in in. Perhaps I should donate it to the FCI…

  • syamir

    i am currently a final year engineering student. for my final year project, i am asked to design my own lab size microwave-vacuum dryer. can u help with the schematics?

    • davearnold

      Hello Syamir,
      I don’t have any schematics. I’d try to find a microwave that has power adjustments instead of adjusting power by turning the magnetron off and on. The next problem will be to measure the temperature of the stuff you are drying without massive arcing. Even without the themometer, I was having huge plasma problems once I appled vacuum. Perhaps I needed to increase the pressure in my vacuum vessel?