Cooking Issues

The International Culinary Center's Tech 'N Stuff Blog

Cooking Issues header image 3

Hydrocolloids Primer

INTRODUCTION TO HYDROCOLLOIDS

Hydrocolloids (aka “gums”) have revolutionized the way many chefs cook. Using hydrocolloids allows a chef create almost any shape and achieve almost any texture using food, all without compromising flavor. In the past, gums have gotten a bad rap among consumers, who perceive them as additives used by industrial food producers for economy and convenience; they can ease fabrication and make products that are cheaper, easier to ship, easier to freeze, and harder to spoil. It doesn’t help that names such as “xanthan gum” and “carboxymethycellulose” just don’t sound appetizing, either. However, as the number of chefs migrating hydrocolloids from additive to ingredient in the pursuit of creating better and more interesting food grows, so increases the number of savvy consumers who abandon prejudices against its usage.

WHAT IS A HYDROCOLLOID?

Hydrocolloids are large molecules that interact with water, and are defined as a type of mechanical mixture where one substance is dispersed evenly throughout water.  A hydrocolloid has colloid particles spread throughout water and depending on the quantity of water available can behave as a gel or liquid. Many hydrocolloids can change their physical behavior and characteristics with the addition or elimination of heat.  They have the ability to thicken and form gels at very low concentrations. Some can be used as whipping agents to make foams, and some act as emulsifiers. With the exception of gelatin (which is a protein), all hydrocolloids are polysaccharides, or complex sugars. When a hydrocolloid is dissolved in water, the water gathers around and is attracted to the sugar units, forming a layer of water with restricted movement. It is this ability to organize and control water that gives hydrocolloids their ability to thicken and gel. The properties of any particular hydrocolloid stem from its physical structure or shape (determined by the sugars it is made from), and its chemical properties: its size, its charge, and the distribution and composition of different side chains along the main sugar chain.

Where Do Hydrocolloids Come From?

Many hydrocolloids are derived from natural sources, such as seaweed, seeds, roots, tree sap, fruit peels, etc. Many cultures have employed some of these naturally-derived hydrocolloids for thousands of years. Agar, for example, comes from seaweed, and is a traditional ingredient in Asia. Carrageenan, known as Irish moss, has been used in traditional Irish cooking for centuries. Gum arabic (tree sap), locust bean gum (seeds of the carob tree), and gelatin have also been used for thousands of years. Pectin, naturally occurring in fruits, has always been used to make jellies and jams.

Some modern but still all-natural hydrocolloids, such as xanthan and gellan, are produced by bacteria. Other hydrocolloids are produced by modifying natural ingredients to create new compounds not found in nature. The most important of these are the cellulose-derived hydrocolloids: methylcellulose, hydroxypropylmethylcellulose, etc. These modified products, while not “all natural,” are still safe.

Since hydrocolloids are derived from natural sources, they are not uniform. Two samples of the same product might have different average molecular weights, and will therefore perform differently. Even the molecules within a given batch of hydrocolloids will vary in size. As a result, commercial manufacturers usually specify a range of weights. By carefully selecting hydrocolloids of different molecular weight, gum manufacturers can also develop products with specialized properties. Some hydrocolloids, such as carrageenan, are made of a mixture of similar but slightly different molecules. The ratios of the different types of molecule vary from batch to batch. Manufacturers blend these hydrocolloids to provide a consistent product, but often the blends will produce consistent results only for a specific application—the mixtures are standardized to do one particular thing very consistently. Many carrageenans, for instance, are standardized to gel milk at a certain strength. The variability in hydrocolloids is one reason that it is not only important to know the name of a hydrocolloid—for example, Alginate—but also its manufacturer and exact specifications, such as alginate, ISP Manugel GHB. When writing recipes, try to list the exact hydrocolloid used.

Hydrocolloid Sources:

source chart

Hydrocolloid Structure

Hydrocolloids are either linear or branched. Most are linear, meaning they are composed of one long chain with small side chains. Branched hydrocolloids, composed of many branches joined together in a bushy shape, include tree gums such as gum arabic and the starch amylopectin. Counterintuitively, branched hydrocolloids typically display lower viscosities (lower viscosity means thinner; higher viscosity means thicker) than linear hydrocolloids of the same size. Branched hydrocolloids are compact, acting like tennis balls, while linear hydrocolloids act like a tangle of spaghetti moving about in solution, taking up more space. For a given hydrocolloid, larger molecules having more sugar units will produce higher viscosities.

Most hydrocolloids have important side groups on their main sugar backbone chain. These side groups affect solubility, gelling ability, susceptibility to salts, etc. Agar and different types of carrageenan (which have very different properties) differ only in their side chain groups. All cellulose derivatives have the same backbone: a cellulose molecule, with different side chains. Sometimes two different hydrocolloids differ only in the distribution of their side chains; the very different properties of locust bean gum and guar gum are the result of a difference only in the way their side chains are arranged.

Textures, Thickening, and Gelling

Hydrocolloids are classified as either thickening or gelling agents. Some common gel texture descriptors are:

Hard/Soft: How much force does it take to rupture the gel?

Brittle/Elastic or Springy: Does the gel break suddenly or deform? After the first bite, does the gel return to its original height?

Cohesive: Is the gel difficult to break up in the mouth? Does it stay together?

Gummy: Is the gel hard and cohesive?

Chewy: Is the gel both gummy and springy?

Adhesive: Does the gel adhere to the teeth or palate?

Characteristics of Gels

Important characteristics of gels are:

Thermo-reversible/Irreversible: Thermo-reversible gels melt when heated to a high enough temperature (with the exception of methylcellulose, which forms thermo-reversible gels that set when heated and melt when cooled).  Thermo-irreversible gels will not melt when heated. Some gels are thermally reversible, but the melting temperature is so high that they don’t melt in practice (high-acyl gellan).

Tendency for Syneresis: Syneresis occurs when liquid weeps out of a gel over time, as happens in custards. Agar is prone to syneresis; water can be expelled merely by pressing on it. Some gels only experience syneresis after long periods of time. Many gels that are ruined by freezing (see freeze-thaw stability, below) tend to weep when thawed. Within a given hydrocolloid system, harder gels tend to weep more than softer ones.

Freeze-thaw stability: Gels that may be frozen and thawed repeatedly are called freeze-thaw stable. Many gels begin to degrade after freezing; only one freeze-thaw cycle is advised. When an unstable gel is frozen and later thawed, its texture and structural may be compromised by the physical changes. To offset this effect and promote freeze-thaw stability, a second thickening hydrocolloid may be added to the gel system.

Clarity: The addition of some hydrocolloids yield gels that are more transparent than others.

Flavor release: Flavor release describes how well a gel expresses the flavorings with which it has been made. Flavor release is determined by many gel texture properties. Gelatin, for example, is considered to have excellent flavor release mainly because it melts in the mouth, whereas alginate is said to have poor flavor release because it tends to lock up flavors.

Shear reversibility: Shear is a force in which parallel objects move in opposite directions in a “sliding” motion, such as in the action of scissors cutting or a razor shaving. Stirring produces a shear, as does blending. Very fast blenders are called high-shear blenders. A shear-reversible gel will reform after it has been broken by a shear force. Most gels are not shear reversible.

Gel Flow Properties

Hydrocolloids that thicken are judged by the flow properties they produce:

Shear thinning: Water has the same viscosity no matter how fast or how hard it is stirred. Liquids that display this characteristic are called Newtonian fluids. Most hydrocolloids, however, display non-Newtonian behavior and tend to get thinner as they are sheared (known as pseudo-plastic behavior). Large tangled hydrocolloid molecules that are aligned randomly in solution tend to be thick. As shear is applied to the solution and the molecules start to move, they tend to align themselves in planes, causing them to grow thinner the more vigorously they are stirred.

Yield point: Some hydrocolloids act like a gel when standing still and liquify instantly under shear. Hydrocolloids with yield points, such as xanthan gum, are useful as stabilizers in foods like salad dressing. The dressing acts like a gel when it’s sitting on the table: the oil droplets stay dispersed in the bottle. But when the dressing is poured, it flows like a liquid. A related term sometimes used synonymously with yield point is thixotropic. Thixotropic fluids, such as ketchup, act as a solid until they are sheared with sufficient force for sufficient time.

Fluid gels: Hydrocolloids can also form fluid gels. Fluid gels have the properties of both a fluid and a gel. Agar fluid gels can look like hair gel on the plate but feel like a smooth, creamy sauce in the mouth. Gellan can make a fluid gel that diners will experience like a soup but that will suspend large particles as if it were solid.

CONSIDERATIONS WHEN USING HYDROCOLLOIDS

Forming Gels

It is extremely important to understand when and why a hydrocolloid gels since this behavior typically determines which hydrocolloid is appropriate to use.

Heating and Cooling

Many hydrocolloids gel when cooled. Sometimes these gels can be melted again, such as gelatin, and sometimes they cannot, such as the pectin in a jam. Methylcellulose forms a gel when heated that melts on cooling. Some thermally reversible gels show temperature hysteresis, that is, the setting temperature of the gel is lower than the temperature needed to melt the gel. This property can be very important to a chef. For example, agar sets around 35°C but melts at around 90°C. The low set temperature makes agar easy to work with, and the high melt temperature allows agar preparations to be served hot. Thermally formed gels can also be slow set or snap set. Snap setting hydrocolloids, like gellan, gel instantly below their gelation temperature.

Calcium and Potassium

Some hydrocolloids form gels in the presence of positively charged ions, mainly calcium and potassium. In these instances, the positive ion fits into negatively charged areas in the hydrocolloid, allowing two hydrocolloid molecules to stick together in a structure similar to an egg-crate. In some cases, like alginates, these gels are not reversible; in others, like kappa carrageenan, thermo-reversible gels are formed. It is extremely important to control the amount of calcium in solution when dealing with calcium-dependent hydrocolloids. If too much calcium is present, the hydrocolloid will gel immediately, a process that is called pre-gelation.

Sometimes, the hydrocolloid simply will not hydrate in a recipe. In these cases, chemicals called sequestrants are added to these solutions to prevent pre-gelation and allow proper hydration. Sequestrants have the ability to bind with ions like calcium more effectively than hydrocolloids can. In many cases, the amount of calcium in tap water alone can cause pre-gelation of a hydrocolloid if not treated with sequestrants. Acidic solutions (low pH) also need more sequestrants than neutral solutions because many calcium impurities are more soluble and affect hydrocolloids more at low pH (see section on calcium salts and sequestrants).

Synergy, 1+1=3

Hydrocolloids do not act like most ingredients. In general, do not expect to be able to mix two hydrocolloids without changing their properties. When two liquids of the same viscosity made with different hydrocolloids are mixed, the viscosity often does not stay the same, but increases. The hydrocolloids have a synergistic increase in viscosity. This effect is used by manufacturers to save money, because they can use a smaller quantity of hydrocolloid in a synergistic system. Another example of synergy is when xanthan gum and locust bean gum, normally non-gelling thickeners, are mixed. Surprisingly, they form a gel. This is called synergistic gelation. Sometimes, hydrocolloids will show synergism with a particular non-hydrocolloid ingredient. For instance, carrageenan plus milk gels at half the concentration of carrageenan plus water.

As a rule of thumb, gelling hydrocolloids and thickening hydrocolloids can often be mixed to get the benefits of both (locust bean gum can be added to kappa carrageenan to give it a better texture, for example) without synergistic effects that will damage a recipe. Charged and uncharged hydrocolloids can also often be mixed without incident, like methylcellulose and alginate (for more information on synergistic effects, see Hydrocolloids, by Andrew C. Hoefler, Eagan Press 2004, page 38).

HYDRATION

For a hydrocolloid to work properly, it must be hydrated and dissolved in solution. When a recipe fails, the problem is frequently improper hydration. Hydration procedures vary from hydrocolloid to hydrocolloid, but there are some important general rules. Hydrocolloids added to water tend to swell as they unfold into solution. The swelling causes particles to clump together forming lumps that are very difficult to dissolve. This phenomenon is familiar to chefs who use starch as a thickener (lumps in the gravy). Many hydrocolloids are even more lump-forming than starch. The trick to hydrating hydrocolloids is to get good dispersion –keep the hydrocolloid particles separated before they start to swell, hydrate, and cause lumps. Industrially, hydrocolloids are often mixed with a non-solvent, like alcohol or corn syrup, or an easily dissolved powder like sugar. This pre-mix helps the hydrocolloid particles get away from each other while they hydrate.

In general, hydrocolloids like to be hydrated in pure water. Large concentrations of sugar, salt, starch, alcohol, or anything that competes with the hydrocolloid for water can hinder hydration. Sometimes a hydrocolloid will not hydrate in a recipe. Alginates, for instance, will not hydrate in acidic liquids. In these cases, the hydrocolloid can be pre-hydrated in pure water, and the resulting solution can usually be added to the recipe without a problem. It is a good practice to add hydrocolloid as early in a recipe as possible.

Recipe Formulations and Measuring

Hydrocolloids are usually specified in percent by weight. One kilogram of 2% alginate solution contains 980 g of water and 20 g of alginate. However, to make a 2% alginate solution, most chefs will add 20 g of alginate to 1000 g of water. Although this mix is technically incorrect (this is a 1.96% solution), the effect of the small additional hydrocolloid is negligible, and this method is easier to calculate. To get consistent results, it is important to use the same method every time. Most hydrocolloid work requires accurate measurement. A scale accurate to 0.1 g is essential; in some cases, it is helpful to have a scale accurate to .01 g.

Calcium Salts and Sequestrants

Calcium sequestrants (chemicals that bind calcium ions) are difficult to understand. The two sequestrants most used by chefs are sodium citrate and sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP). Sodium citrate only works in systems above a pH of 4, while SHMP works in all the pH ranges a chef will ever use. For most applications, SHMP at 0.1% will provide good sequestering ability.

Different recipes specify the use of different calcium salts. The three most common are calcium chloride, calcium lactate, and calcium lactate gluconate. Calcium chloride is 36% calcium, is inexpensive, and is very soluble in water, but has a terrible taste. Calcium lactate is 13% calcium, is more expensive, and is not nearly as soluble as calcium chloride, but it tastes much better. Calcium lactate gluconate, or calcium gluconate, is only 9% calcium, is much more expensive than the others, and is not very soluble—it needs to be dissolved in hot water, but is flavorless. In recipes, calcium chloride baths are usually between 0.8 – 1.5%. Calcium lactate and calcium gluconate are usually used in quantities between 2–5%.

Dispersion & Dissolution

Hydrocolloids that form gels are easily dispersed when conditions are favorable for gelling.  Dispersion (getting hydrocolloid particles as far away from each other as possible before they start to absorb water and swell) is simple to do when a hydrocolloid is added to water in a state favoring gelling because they are not soluble in that state.

Dissolution cannot happen when conditions are favorable for gelling. Gelatin cannot be dissolved in cold water. Kappa carrageenan cannot be dissolved in potassium-filled cold water. Hydrocolloid recipes often call for the addition of a hydrocolloid in conditions that favor gelling, to allow dispersion, and then specify putting the hydrocolloid in a condition that doesn’t favor gelling, to allow dissolution and hydration.

Hydration tip

A chef’s best friend in hydration is the blender, and it’s worth it to get a good one. Blenders use high shear to beat particles away form each other and achieve good dispersion throughout a mixture.

Here’s a good technique: Add liquid to the blender, then select a speed that forms a vortex in the liquid without a lot of splashing. Slowly sprinkle the hydrocolloid in the center of the vortex until it is thoroughly dispersed. Continue blending on high until the mixture is hydrated.

HYDROCOLLOID PROFILES

GELATIN

Structure: protein
Origin: animal
Form: sheets and powder
Function: gelling, also acts as a whipping agent and stabilizer

Special Characteristics
Gelatin has excellent flavor release and mouthfeel because it melts at body temperature. Its texture is excellent. Gelatin swells in cold water but must be heated to dissolve. Gelatin can be dissolved in a small portion of a recipe’s liquid and then stirred into the remaining liquid so that the entire batch does not have to be heated.

Use
Hydration: allow gelatin to swell in cold water for several minutes; add to hot liquid (over 60°C/140°F) and stir until dissolved
Level: Typical usage is roughly 1.0 to 1.5%
Gel type: thermo-reversible
Gel temperature: ~35°C (95°F)
Hysteresis: no
Setting: slow set
PH tolerance: moderate
Freeze/thaw stable: no
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: breaks gel
Appearance: clear and bright
Flavor release: excellent
Other effects: sugar and alcohol softens gelatin gels

Gelatin Clarification:
Clarification is a very exciting gelatin application. Because gelatin is not freeze-thaw stable, almost any liquid that is cloudy due to suspended protein (including stocks, broths, juices, and purées) can be clarified using gelatin without having to boil the liquid or form an egg-white raft: A small amount of gelatin (roughly 0.5%) is dissolved in the liquid to be clarified, which is then frozen and allowed to thaw.

As the mixture thaws, the gelatin block will weep out clarified liquid, leaving the protein and cloudiness behind. In the following recipe, a stock is clarified using its own gelatin. When using this technique on a regular stock with no added gelatin, it is important that the stock not be too firmly gelled, or yield will be low. Stock that almost sets when cold is good enough. Once clarified, the stock will no longer contain gelatin, so the texture and usage will be very different from a traditional clarified stock. Of course, gelatin can be added back to regain a traditional mouthfeel.

CARRAGEENAN

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of galactose units with sulfate side groups
Origin: Red seaweeds
Types: Kappa, iota, lambda (not discussed)

Special Characteristics
Natural carrageenans are always come in a mixture of kappa, iota, and lambda types. Manufacturers try to separate the types as best as possible, but total separation is impossible. Carrageenans also vary from batch to batch and are, therefore, standardized for a particular application. When specifying carrageenan, tell the manufacturer whether the application is for a water-based system or a milk-based system. Carrageenans are often used in milk-based applications because they are effective at very low concentrations. Gels can be formed at 0.3% in milk. Kappa and iota carrageenans can be mixed to obtain intermediate textures. Kappa carrageenan shows synergism with the thickener locust bean gum. The addition of locust bean gum makes kappa carrageenan gels stronger, less brittle, more cohesive, and less prone to syneresis. The strongest synergy occurs when mixed in the ratio of 6 parts kappa carrageenan to 4 parts LBG. Kappa-LBG mixes, as they are called, are often used as a substitute for gelatin. Kappa-LBG with the required amount potassium salt is sold pre-mixed.

Use
Hydration: disperse in cold water or milk under shear and heat until completely dissolved, usually above 60°C. Kappa-LBG mixes need to be brought almost to the boil to become fully functional, but will set and re-melt at lower temperatures. Solutions up to 3% can be made using cold water dispersion. Solutions as high as 8% can be made if the carrageenan is dissolved directly into very hot water under high shear.

Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.75% to 1% in water and 0.35% to 0.5% in milk.

Kappa Carageenan
Function:gelling
Gel type: thermo-reversible
Texture: firm, strong, and brittle
Syneresis: yes
Gel temperature: increases with ion concentration, with values ranging from 40°C to 70°C
Hysteresis: yes, 10 to 15°C
Setting: fast set
PH tolerance: down to pH 3.6 if boiled, lower if not overheated
Freeze/thaw stable: no
Ion sensitive: yes, requires potassium salts to form gel, but is often sold with the needed potassium already present.
Shearing: breaks gel
Appearance: hazy on its own but clear if sugar is added
Flavor release: good
Other effects: forms gels at very low concentrations with milk

 

Iota Carageenan
Function:gelling
Gel type: thermo-reversible
Texture: elastic and cohesive
Syneresis: not as much as kappa
Gel temperature: increases with ion concentration, with values ranging from 40°C to 70°C
Hysteresis: negligible
Setting: fast set
PH tolerance: down to pH 3.6 if boiled, lower if not over-heated
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: yes, gels in the presence of calcium or potassium, but is most sensitive to calcium
Shearing: gel will re-form after shear
Appearance: hazy on its own but clear if sugar is added
Flavor release: good
Other effects: forms gels at very low concentrations with milk

AGAR

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made ofgalactose units
Origin: Red seaweeds
Function: gelling

Special Characteristics
Agar is very similar in structure to carrageenan. It lacks only carrageenan’s sulfate groups. Agar’s temperature hysteresis is very large compared to most hydrocolloids. Agar gels can be served hot. As a gel that forms quickly upon cooling but does not melt easily, agar is a prime candidate for cold-oil spherification. Liquid agar at roughly 45 to 50°C is dropped into cold oil where it solidifies into balls. These balls are rinsed with hot water and served. Agar also forms good fluid gels. Sauces with consistencies from hair gel to almost liquid on the plate can be created that have very smooth mouthfeels.

Agar is one of the few hydrocolloids that is available in many grocery stores, especially Asian grocery stores. Agar has been a traditional ingredient in Asia for hundreds of years.

Use
Hydration: disperse in cold liquid and heat while stirring until completely dissolved, usually above 90°C.
Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.5% to 1%
A Note about Agar Fluid Gels
Making a fluid gel with agar is simple. Make a normal agar gel in the range of 0.6% to 1.2% agar and shear the gel in a blender until a smooth consistency is contained. Agar fluid gels can be thinned with liquid or thickened with xanthan gum. Agar fluid gels can be served hot (do not bring near boiling).
Gel type: thermo-reversible
Texture: firm, strong, and brittle
Syneresis: yes
Gel temperature: approximately 35°C
Hysteresis: dramatic, roughly 50°C to 55°C
Setting: fast set
PH tolerance: good, similar to carrageenan, but do not keep acidic solutions hot for very long or the agar will begin to break down
Freeze/thaw stable: no
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: breaks gel, can form fluid gels
Appearance: slightly hazy in high concentration
Flavor release: good

SODIUM ALGINATE

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of mannuronic (M) acid and guluronic (G) acid units.
Origin: Brown seaweeds
Types: High M and High G (discussed together)
Function: gelling

Special Characteristics
Sodium alginate (usually referred to as alginate) very quickly forms rigid brittle gels that are completely heat stable in the presence of calcium. Alginate gels are formed either through internal setting, or through diffusion setting. In internal setting, a time-release form of calcium is used in the alginate solution. This type of gel forms from the inside. Chefs usually use the diffusion method, where alginate is dropped into a calcium bath. The calcium sets the outside and slowly diffuses to the center of the gel, making it completely solid. The best-known commercial application of this effect is the pimento strip inside a cocktail olive, which is made from pepper purée and alginate.

Ferran Adrià popularized this hydrocolloid by making alginate “caviar.” Alginate solution is dropped into a calcium bath where it instantly sets into a small ball. Unfortunately, this preparation has to be done à la minute, because the balls solidify rather quickly and don’t have much flavor when completely gelled. Diffusion setting can also be done in reverse, where a thickened, flavorful liquid with calcium is dropped into an alginate bath. This produces a liquid center with an alginate skin and is usually called “the reverse alginate technique.” The calcium containing centers can also be frozen before they are dropped into the alginate, which makes neater shapes than dropping a liquid into a liquid. It is difficult to make small balls using the reverse alginate technique. Finally, alginate can be gelled by spraying it with a calcium solution out of a squirt-bottle. This technique is useful to set large areas of alginate than can’t easily be dunked in a bath.

The most common calcium salt used to make calcium solution is calcium chloride (which has a terrible taste). Other salts are available (see the section on calcium salts and sequestrants).

The percentage of alginate in a solution is important in determining gel texture, but the percentage calcium in the setting bath is important too. Stronger calcium baths (higher salt percentages) not only set alginate faster, they set it harder. Alginate gelled in a weak calcium bath will never be as strong as one gelled in a strong calcium bath, because the ultimate strength of an alginate gel is dependant on how fast it sets. Typical alginate “caviars” are roughly .75-1% alginate and are set in a 1-2% calcium chloride or 5% calcium lactate or calcium gluconate bath.

After setting, alginate gels set in calcium chloride or calcium lactate should be rinsed in a water bath to remove bitterness. Calcium gluconate does not need to be rinsed.

Set alginates should be stored in a storage bath. If stored in normal water, alginate gels will leach out their color and flavor rather quickly. It is a good idea to store the gels in something with a similar flavor and color as the original gel. A small amount of calcium lactacte or calcium gluconate (0.5-1%) can be added to the storage bath to maintain texture.

Use
Hydration: disperse under shear using the vortex method described in the hydration section until completely dissolved. If using hard water, flavors with calcium, or acids, add sequestrants before adding alginate(see the section on calcium salts and sequestrants). In acidic conditions, alginate should first be hydrated in pure water with sequestrant and then added to the recipe.
Level:  Typical usage is roughly 0.5 to 1%.
Gel type: not thermally reversible
Texture: strong, and brittle (High G, High M slightly
more elastic)
Syneresis: some, increasing with increasing gel strength
Gel temperature: most alginate solutions are independent of temperature
Hysteresis: NA
Setting: snap set
PH tolerance: good if precautions are taken to allow hydration and prevent pre-gelling. Some alginates work down to pH 3.6 others only tolerate a pH of 5 and above
Freeze/thaw stable: depends
Ion sensitive: yes, forms gels in the presence of calcium.
Shearing: normally breaks gel
Appearance: clear and bright
Flavor release: hard set gels have poor flavor release
Other effects: thick gels do not break apart well in
the mouth

LOCUST BEAN GUM (LBG)

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of a galactose and mannose chain (a galactomannan) with galactose side units
Origin: The seed of the carob tree. LBG is also known as St. John’s Bread
Function: Thickening and stabilization

Special Characteristics
LBG has been in use for thousands of years and is widely used as a stabilizer and thickener. LBG is especially interesting because of its synergistic properties with other hydrocolloids (see the section on carrageenan)

Use
Hydration: hydrate in cold or hot water under shear.
Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.5 to 1%.
Solution type: shear thinning (pseudo-plastic), no yield point
PH tolerance: down to pH 3.6 if boiled, lower if not overheated
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: decreases viscosity which returns after shear
Appearance: often hazy, but a new, clear variety has recently become available
Other effects: Has synergistic effects with many hydrocolloids including carrageenan and xanthan gum. LBG xanthan mixtures form a gel

GUM ARABIC

Structure: Branched polysaccharide made of several different sugar units with a substantial amount of attached protein impurities
Origin: Tree sap
Function: Emulsifying, adhering, and gelling in very high percentages

Special Characteristics
Gum Arabic has been used for thousands of years and has always been collected the same way. It isn’t used as a thickener, but as an emulsifier, since it does not thicken until very high concentrations are reached. The small amount of protein present in gum arabic gives it its emulsifying properties. Highly concentrated flavor mixtures can be emulsified with gum arabic, stored, and then diluted without breaking the emulsion.

Use
Hydration: hydrate in cold or hot water under shear
Level: Typical usage is roughly 1% to 40%
Solution type: almost Newtonian until very high concentrations are reached
PH tolerance: high
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: no effect
Appearance: clear
Other effects: emulsifies flavored oils in water and can be diluted without breaking the emulsion

PECTIN

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of galactose units with methylester side groups
Origin: Fruit, especially citrus peels and apple pomace
Types: High methoxy (HM), low methoxy (LM) and low methoxy amidated (LMA).

Special Characteristics
HM pectin is the pectin found in jams. It requires acidic environments with large amounts of sugar to gel properly. Different grades of HM pectin are sold based on how fast they set after cooling. Rapid-set HM pectin gels almost instantly below about 85°C. Medium rapidset gels in 5 minutes at 75°C. Slowset takes 30 minutes to set at 65°C.

LM and LMA pectins can produce similar results as HM pectins can, but they don’t require acidic conditions or high soluble solids. They do, however, require calcium. They can be set just like alginate. LM pectins are more finicky about calcium levels than LMA pectins, so chefs mainly use LMA pectins.

Use
Hydration: disperse in cold water or milk under shear and heat until completely dissolved
Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.35% to 1%

High Methoxy Pectin
Function: gelling
Gel type: thermally irreversible
Texture: from jam to pates de fruit texture
Syneresis: no
Gel temperature: values ranging from 65°C to 95°C.
Hysteresis: N/A
Setting: different based on type
PH tolerance: requires a pH below 3.8 to gel
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: breaks gel
Appearance: clear and bright
Flavor release: excellent
Other effects: requires low pH (below 3.8 to 3.1) and high soluble solids (sugar, typically above 55% to 65%) to gel

Low Methoxy and Low Methoxy Amidated Pectin
Function: Gelling
Gel type: thermo-reversible
Texture: from jam to pâte de fruit texture
Syneresis: no
Gel temperature: increases with ion concentration, with values ranging from 30°C to 60°C
Hysteresis: negligible
Setting: fast set
PH tolerance: high
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: yes, requires calcium to gel
Appearance: clear and bright

CELLULOSE DERIVATIVES: METHOCEL

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of a cellulose backbone units with various side groups
Origin: Cellulose, often from cotton
Types: Methylcellulose (MC), hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC) (both sold under the Methocel brand by Dow), Hydroxypropylcellulose (HPC) (not discussed), and Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) (not discussed).
  DOW METHOCEL
Function: gelling, film forming, whipping

Types
Methocel comes in 5 types SG A, A, E, F and K. Each of these types comes in several different viscosities. There are 19 types in all.

SG A: SG stands for super-gel. This series is made from methylcellulose (MC) and gels at a very low temperature, 38°C to 44°C. It forms firm rigid gels.

A: this series is made from MC and forms a firm gel between 50°C and 55°C, but not as firm as the SG A.

E: this series is made from HPMC and forms a semi-firm gel between 58°C and 64°C. HPMC is more tolerant of acid than MC. E series gums are excellent film-formers and can be used to make flavored papers and strips.

F: this series is made from HPMC and forms a semi-firm gel between 63°C and 68°C. The F series is fantastic for making foams.

K: this series is made from HPMC and forms a soft gel between 70°C and 90°C.

Use
Hydration: Many Methocels can be hydrated directly using the vortex method in cold liquid. F50, the favorite Methocel for foams, works this way. The SG A and A series can be hydrated this way but not reliably. If Methocel has been properly hydrated, the solutions will become clear, thicken appreciably, and set when a small ball of solution is dropped in hot oil (but not above 100°C). To reliably hydrate Methocel, add it to hot liquid above the gel temperature of the series being used, shear, and add enough cold liquid or ice to drop the temperature below the gel point. After the solution is cooled enough, the Methocel will hydrate.

Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.75% to 2%
Gel type: thermo-reversible, gels when heated
Texture: depends on type
Gel temperature: depends on type and ranges from 38°C to 90°C
Hysteresis: minimal
Setting: fast
PH tolerance: moderate
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: breaks gel
Appearance: gel is milky white, solution is clear
Flavor release: good

XANTHAN GUM

Structure: linear polysaccharide made of a cellulose backbone units with trisaccharide side chains
Origin: the microbe Xanthomonas campestris
Function: thickening

Special Characteristics
Xanthan is a wonder gum. It is very user friendly and can be added to sauces without weighing. It works at any temperature. Be careful not to add too much or foods can become snot-like.

Use
Hydration: disperse in hot or cold liquid under shear.
Level: Typical usage is roughly 0.2% to 1%.
Solution type: shear thinning (pseudo-plastic), definite yield point
Texture: in high levels, xanthan can give foods a mucous-like consistency
PH tolerance: high
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: no
Shearing: under very low shear, xanthan solution acts like a gel. More shear turns the solution into a shear thinning fluid.
Appearance: clear
Other effects: reacts synergistically with LBG to form a gel

GELLAN

Structure: Linear polysaccharide made of repeating glucose, rhamnose, and glucuronic acid units with acyl side groups.
Origin: the microbe Sphingomonas elodea
Types: High acyl and low acyl

High Acyl Gellan
Function: Gelling

Special Characteristics
The textures of high and low acyl gellan fall on opposite ends of the gel scale. High acyl is soft and elastic while low acyl is hard and brittle. The two types can be mixed together to generate intermediate textures. High acyl texture tends to dominate. A middle of the texture spectrum ratio would be 75% low acyl to 25% high acyl gellan. It is easy to form gels that form on cooling with gellan, but it is also possible to form caviar balls with low acyl gellan in a calcium bath. The advantage over alginate is better flavor release. Unfortunately, low acyl gellan is extremely sensitive to calcium, potassium, and even sodium salts when used this way. Typically only salt-free flavors like fruits can be made. Gellan is so finicky with calcium that deionized water is recommended and sequestrants are necessary. Both types of gellan form fluid gels but typically the low acyl is used. Very liquid fluid gels can be made this way, much thinner than agar.

Use
Hydration: For normal temperature setting, mix gellan with liquid (and calcium if using low acyl gellan) under shear and heat until the fluid becomes clear and the gellan is dissolved. For calcium setting, add sequestrants to liquid and, using the vortex method, add low acyl gellan to liquid under high shear.
Level: Typical usage is roughly .04% to 1%.
Gel type: thermo-reversible when heated a long time. Milk gels are more easily melted
Texture: elastic, springy, cohesive
Syneresis: yes
Gel temperature: increases with ion concentration, with values ranging from 65°C to 70°C
Hysteresis: yes
Setting: snap set
PH tolerance: good
Freeze/thaw stable: yes
Ion sensitive: yes, calcium and potassium increase gel temperature and strength, but are not needed for setting
Shearing: breaks gel or forms fluid gel
Appearance: hazy
Flavor release: good

Low Acyl Gellan
Function: Gelling
Gel type: not thermally reversible
Texture: firm and brittle
Syneresis: not usually
Gel temperature: increases with ion concentration, with values ranging from 30°C to 50°C.
Hysteresis: NA
Setting: snap set
PH tolerance: moderate
Freeze/thaw stable: no
Ion sensitive: yes, gels in the presence of calcium or potassium, but is most sensitive to calcium.
Shearing: breaks gel or forms fluid gel.
Appearance: clear
Flavor release: very good

55 Comments

55 Comments so far ↓

  • Elias

    I am sorry if I am being stupid, but I see guar gum is not included in the above hydrocolloids. Maybe you can add a primer for it as well?

    • Dave A

      Elias,
      Sorry about that. I’ll look into it. The Guar we use is TIC Gums Flavor Free guar. All other guar I’ve tried tastes bad. Guar and LBG are made of the same sugar units as each-other, but the side units on guar are evenly spaced, while on LBG they are irregularly spaced. It is for this reason that Guar will hydrate in cold water while LBG needs to be heated above 70C and why LBG has synergistic effects with other gums like Xanthan while guar doesn’t. Guar is usually cheaper than LBG which is why it is so often used commercially. It also sounds like the death-metal band GWAR, which never fails to make me laugh.

      • Elias

        Dave, thank you very much! I knew that LBG and guar (also called guarana, so it will not make you laugh:) are similar in structure. I use it to make dondurma, the stretchy turkish ice cream that McGee described. I am greek, so it is part of our cuisine (although I live in england the last 10 years…). Never had a problem with flavour, I guess it is all the fat and sugar in the ice cream that mask it. Since I recently found out that milk for ice cream develops enzymes when heated to 79C, that contribute to flavour, maybe I could use LGB instead? Thanks again

      • Ethan

        GWAR isn’t death metal…

  • Michael Natkin

    I don’t understand the distinction being made between (shear thinning, shear plasticity) and (yield point, and thixotropy). Do all four of those describe the same behavior or are there two or four different things here?

    • Dave A

      Howdy Michael,
      I don’t know about shear plasticity, But shear thinning, yield point, and thixotropy are different but related.
      Anything that appears to get thinner as it is stirred is shear-thinning. The physical explanation for this is that without shear, hydrocolloids act like a jumbled mat of pasta, which gives a lot of resistance to stirring, but as you stir harder, the stands start to line up and can slip past eachother more easily.
      Yield point is when something acts like a gel when it is not under shear, and then suddenly gives way and becomes a shear thinning liquid. Xanthan solutions are like this (which is why they can suspend particles). Gums without a yield point, like guar, will still flow under low shear even if they move quite slowly.
      Thixotropy is when something is increasingly shear thinning over time. The longer you stir it the thinner it gets. Usually it also takes a while to regain its at rest viscocity.
      If anyonelse else has something to add please chime in. Hope this helps.

  • Paul R

    Great Summary, thanks so much.

    I’m wondering if you could address a couple of questions.

    I often use hydrocolloids to substitute for other more traditional colloids when I feel there are advantages. For example, in thickening brown sauces, I’d like to simulate the mouthfeel of highly reduced gelatin, without its drawbacks (stickiness, tendency to congeal on the plate). In making ice cream I want the consistency given by egg custard, but not the flavor of cooked egg yolk.

    Do you have any ideas on hydrocolloids that would work in these or in similar situations?

    Currently I’m using a mix of natural gelatin and xanthan in the brown sauces, and added gelatin and xanthan in the ice cream. But there is so much I haven’t had a chance to try.

    • Evan

      Hey Paul,
      I can offer you an alternative to your ice cream problem. You said that you wanted the consistency given by a egg custard base ice cream, but not the flavor of the cooked yolks, so to do this you will need to adapt a modern ice cream making technique. Using the classic ice cream method you will always have the egg yolk flavor even with the addition of hydrocolloids, but lets avoid the entire classic method all together.

      Here is the “mother” recipe for modern, non-custard based ice creams:
      Whole Milk 73.59%
      Milk Powder 10.06%
      Sugar 10.67%
      Glucose Powder 6.00%
      Trimoline 1.33%
      Stabilizer-Emulsifier Mix 0.35%
      Flavor 0.00%

      Scale all the ingredients accurately, mix 10% of the sugar with the stabilizer-emulsifier mix, place whole milk in a heavy sauce pot and add the milk powder and flavoring, turn on the heat and whisk continually, pour in all forms of sugar at 100˚F, at 113˚F add heavy cream if you are mixing it with the whole milk, at 120˚F add the hydrocolloid/sugar mix, use a stick blender to disperse the hydrocolloid mix until full hydration, continue to stir the mixture until it reaches 180˚F, pass the mixture through a chinois and rapidly chill, age the base for 4hrs minimum.

      If pacotizing, place base in a beaker and freeze solid, then run the cycle.

      If churning, give the base a good stir before adding it to the batch freezer. Churn to 18˚F.

      Reserve ice cream in a 14˚F freezer for service.

      The Stabilizer-Emulsifier Mix is composed of:
      100g Xanthan Gum
      175g CP Kelco Unflavored Locust Bean Gum
      175g TIC Gums Pretested Flavorless Guar Gum
      50g Mono-glycerides
      50g Di-glycerides
      [Mix all ingredients together, then sift and store in an airtight container.]

      This is a basic recipe you can obviously modify to your needs, but I recommend you stay within the minimum and maximum limits of adding and subtracting ingredients for this to work. The min. and max. are:

      Fats [from milk, heavy cream, butter, egg yolks, any dairy product] Minimum=7% Maximum=11%

      Stabilizers [Minimum=0.30% Maximum=1.00%]

      Emulsifiers [Minimum=0.20% Maximum=0.30%]

      Non-Fat Solids [If using egg yolks they are considered to be 50% fat solids so factor that into the Fats as well] Including garnishes. Minimum=24.00% Maximum=30.00%

      Total Solids [Includes all fats in all forms plus any added ingredients] Minimum=31.00% Maximum=41.00%

      Liquid [Any and all ingredients minus the solids, including fats] Minimum and Maximum are 100% – Solid%.

      Sugars [Any sugar in any form.] Minimum=16.00% Maximum=23.00%

      Flavoring [Minimum=2% Maximum=10%]

      So now you have a base to work off of, and you can create your own ice creams without egg yolks or their flavor they put in ice cream.

      If you have any questions I learned how to make this style of ice cream from Chef Francisco Migoya, ex. Executive Pastry Chef for Thomas Keller. He is a great acquaintance of mine, so if you need any more information I can put you in contact with him.

      • Miss M.

        Evan,

        I am trying to make fat free, sugar free gelato and sugar-free sorbet, and I was very interested in your Stabilizer-Emulsifier Mix because I have xantham gum, guar gum and LBG at home and could mix it myself. Can I use this mix without the glycerides? Or, if I have to use glycerides, are there any replacements for them that I could use at home? (soy lecithin or others)?

        What would happen if I didn’t use xantham gum? What proportions would I need of LBG and guar gum? Thanks a lot!

        Finally, could you put me in touch with Francisco Migoya? I have some questions that I would like to ask.

      • cholo

        hi evan , im planning on making your “non-custard based ice cream” but i can’t seem to find any or understand what are Mono-glycerides and Di-glycerides for the stabilizer-emulsifier mix.
        Can you suggest any vegan type and where can i get some.

  • Jens

    Lets say we are making a gel with pieces of meat in it. For the gel we want to use reduced meat stock (A sylta in swedish, ask Nils). And id rather use gellan than agar so that it dont have to worry about it melting during service.

    If the stock is to reduced the gel gets soft and crumbly. Why is that? To much calcium and potassium? I have tried adding sodium citrate, not sure if it helps thought.

    I have also noticed that if i start with cold stock, gellan and meat in a pot and bring to boil, i get a bad gel. But if i use the same stock, bring to boil with gellan and then add hot pieces of meat i get a good gel

  • TS Gordon

    Is it safe to assume that I will need a good working knowledge of all of the above technology if I am to achieve my near-term goals of creating some uniquely marketable ‘all-natural’ pre-packaged pastries, with a shelf-life of 2 weeks to 1 month?

    I envision, for example, creating a 1/2 domed plated desert consisting of a candied 1/2 pear atop an apricot coated, flakey cookie-like pastry, with a light, (lemon mouse-like) center filling, and a hard-coating of chocolate covering the lot.

    That said, I hope Nils & Co will welcome an overtly curious ‘newbie’ to this forum, and (with any luck,) enable me to progress with my career studies without formally entering the (cost prohibitive) ranks of NYC academia.

    Note, I am truly overwhelmed at the mere thought of attending even a single lecture at the Culinary Institute, after a rather lack-lustre 20+ year career in photography , and recently building home theaters.

    From here to retirement, I plan to do nothing other than food service work. Our family has operated this Mexican (Tex-Mex) restaurant in Arkansas for 30 years. http://juanitas.com

  • Ken

    What is a good storage medium (if there is one) for reverse spherified yogurt balls? Can it be held in plain water overnight, or does it need a low percentage alginated water solution?

  • Lauren

    Dave, sorry if I missed this somewhere, but do you know a good place in NYC to purchase Methocel f50, Xanthan gum, gellan gum, sodium alginate, and tapioca maltodextrin? I’ve seen it online at various places, but I remember you telling us on the spice tour a few weeks back that product quality can vary. I’m about to begin a blogging project, cooking my way through Johnny Iuzzini’s Foreplay, so I’m stocking up. Thanks!

    • Dave A

      Howdy Lauren,
      I would go online. The local varieties of xanthan will be fine but the other stuff is more specialized. Be sure you don’t buy any old tapioca maltodextrin. You need N-Zorbit tapioca maltodextrin.

  • Ume

    Hi guys, thank you for the great primer. I was hoping to ask a question. I’ve been working more with various gelling agents, and one particular application is a vegetarian marshmallow with a rich texture. My current (unsuccessful approach) has been to use a base of sugar + corn syrup (225g total) + 40ml water brought to 118C. To this I add a carrageenan + LBG (10g) cold dispersion in 110ml and brought back to the boil. This is mixed into 1 stiff egg white. My results have varied with tweaking from very sticky goo which never fully hardens to a cream/suspension which i must admit has a wonderful mouthfeel but fails to harden. Regardless the marshmallow texture eludes me. Xanthan gum has been tried but isn’t v. stable at room temp, agar doesn’t work well. I was hoping you might shed some light?

  • Michael @ Herbivoracious.com

    Best vegan marshmallows I’ve had are Dandies brand. Their ingredient list is corn syrup, vegan beet sugar, corn starch, corn dextrose, water, carageenan, soy protein, natural vanilla flavor, titanium dioxide, salt. No idea of process or exact ratios, but it should be a starting point.

  • Ume

    Hi Dave, just thought I’d let you know I managed to solve my issues with the marshmallows. I eded up using less carrageenan+LBG and added in xanthan gum to the egg-white to help stabilise it. The final recipe is on this blog:

    http://seventypercentcocoa.wordpress.com/

    Thanks again for the help!

    • davearnold

      Hey Ume, glad you solved your problem. We did a couple of failed recipes. I got a hold of CPKelco. They recommended Genutine x 9303.

  • David Porras

    hi do you have any information about egg white powder

  • Pedro P.

    Hi everybody. Thanks in advance for your help and patience. I´m working on Vegetarian sausages and I’ve been using Methocell A4M, Kappa Carragenan, Soy Isolates and Gluten Vital. I’d got an aproximate texture on warm temp but, as I´m Strict LActo-Vegetarian, I don’t use any egg white and I’m having a very soft texture in room or cold temp. Any suggestions please?

    • davearnold

      Why are you using Methocel for this application? It will gel when hot but melt as it cools. Perhaps that is the problem.

      • Pedro P.

        Hi Dave: Thanks. It was a formulation given by CP Kelco using Methocell + Carrageenan (GenuText. MA-1). If you could sugest any formulation to do a Veggetarian Frankfurter without egg whites and have a good texture I’m hearing… Thanks again.

      • Pedro P.

        Hi Dave, is there any suggestions on my subject. What to use instead of Methocell? Thanks.

  • marv woodhouse

    Hi,

    Having become rapidly addicted to the blog and podcast I am really quite excited to find a technology that is fairly accessible to me. I work in the pharma industry and use most of these polymers on a daily basis to manipulate the physical properties of pharmaceutical mixtures.

    Will do some experimentation.

  • patrik

    “Carrageenan, known as Irish moss, has been used in traditional Irish cooking for centuries”

    Could you give some examples of use in traditional Irish cooking?

  • Vu

    Hey Dave Arnold,

    I think I found an error within your primer on hydrocolloids. Under the section “Calcium Salts and Sequestrants” you stated that calcium lactate only contains 13% calcium, shouldn’t the correct value be 18%?
    I do not know how you determined the value of 13% calcium in calcium lactate but the molar mass of calcium lactate is 218.22 g/mol and 40.078 g/mol for calcium, so taking 40.078 g/mol divided by 218.22 g/mol multiplied by 100% will equal to roughly 18% calcium in calcium lactate. I do believe this is the correct value instead of 13% because I used this similar method to determine the values of calcium within calcium gluconate and calcium chloride to be 9% and 36%, respectively, which were the values you stated above.
    I think this will prevent any miscalculations when determining the right amount of calcium lactate to use for things such as spherification.

    Thanks.

  • Christine

    Your RSS feed link is broken

  • jason

    What’s a trick for making alcohol fruit jellys? I have experimented with Gelatin and Pectin (separately) hydrated in pure water, allowed to cool below 75C, then mixed with fruit flavoring and 80 Proof vodka and refrigerated. Flavoring and alcohol content worked but to much syneresis at room temperature. Thanks.

    • davearnold

      Howdy Jason,
      Do you want jelly like jello or jelly like a fruit spread? For jelly like jello I’d use gellan, mostly low acyl with a bit of high tossed in. If you are having problems with the temperature on that (can’t keep the temp high enough to prevent pre-gelling when adding liquor), I would use a kappa carrageenan locust bean gum mix. CP Kelco sells one that has a non-cloudy LBG in it that they use for a gelatin replacer in hot countries.

  • sigma

    So, I’ve been using gellan according to a few recipes in Modernist Cuisine and from El Bulli and I notice that I am getting a weird clumping after the concoction comes to a boil, almost an odd, curdled mess. I dispersed in a thermomix for 1 minute each time, so that shouldn’t be the problem. Any thoughts? help?

  • rocky

    Great summary. So I have heard a few rumors of gels that are fryable. Or at least one that can handle 300 degrees of heat without melting. I have tried TG but only have gotten it to cataylize tofu protein and tofu is not gelly enough for my purposes. Tried it with agar and no effect.

  • Rusty Wright

    Can any of these be used as a substitute for pectin when making jams and jellies? I remember reading that jams and jellies use a lot of sugar in order to counteract the sour pectin. I would like to be able to make jams and jellies that do not have a ton of sugar in them.

    • davearnold

      Use want to use a Low Methoxy Amidated (LMA) pectin. They still like high soluble solids, but don’t need anywhere near the amount of sugar regular pectin does. That is what the pros use. You do need to add some calcium to the recipe.

  • BrianO

    Hi

    I’m not a chef, but a painter (art). I found this fascinating primer on Hydrocolloids that I’m using in various experimental paintings I’m working on.

    I’m trying to achieve the following -

    I’d like to mix pigment into a paste-like gel or gelatin that will set or freeze with temperature to a fairly firm point (to handle a mold). Then I would like to re-liquify the mixture with temperature (hopefully room temperature) to the same workable paste-like gel I started with.

    Obviously, the gel/gum would need to be as clear as possible and archival (like gum arabic).

    Any ideas you have would be greatly appreciated!

    • davearnold

      Methocell sets when it gets hot and turns liquid again when it gets cold –which would work, but although it is a clear liquid it dries white (I think). Gelatin will melt only slightly hotter than room temp, you could then use a thickener like xanthan to make it goopy. A xanthan goop set with gelatin. I believe both of those will dry clear (but I’m not absolutely sure).

  • Lea

    I’m working on a vegan burger. I’ve achieved the flavor and texture that I’m looking for, but the mix is still too soft, not firm enough to ensure that it will hold together in restaurant use. What do you suggest?

  • Mike

    I ve been wantung to work in rigid sheet that melts in your to delive a digedtfe.or a mint flavor. I was unsure if methocel would.be correct becausee it.does exactly oppositely tjat and ive never heard,of a rigis sheet of gelatin. So a starting point be appreciated

    • davearnold

      Do you mean like listerine strips? they use a hydrocolloid called pullulan. Some chefs use Methocel for sips, but they come out more like paper. I don’t like them. The one they used to use is Methocel e-15 from Dow. Not made anymore. Can’t remember closest substitute.

  • Ratio Rally – Gluten Free Bread

    [...] lot of people I know prefer not to use hydrocolloids in gluten free baking due to sensitivities or other reasons, but GF bread is one place I’ve [...]

  • Dave A

    Hello Ume,
    Interesting problem. We are actually going to be wotking on a similar problem soon. I know the commercial ones are made with Carrageenan. I didn’t see LBG on the lable but I was thinking of adding it as well because Kappa/LBG is a good gelatin substitute. Did yours whip up fine and just not harden?

  • Ume

    I’ve tried to main iterations of this recipe, they all whipped up fine, and taste very much like a marshmallow cream. In my original attempt:

    110mls of corn syrup + 225g sugar
    10g carageenan mix
    50ml water

    Mix all these together and heat to soft ball (118C until thickened). Rapidly mix into beaten egg white until thick. This produced a very sticky but soft result. Over a period of several days it forms a crust which made it quite marshmallow like, however if you cut through it was still sticky and too pliable to handle underneath. One thing I did differently was that in this early attempt I used 2 egg whites, as I was unsure about proportions. I haven’t repeated it with one egg, but I may try that at some point.

    Iteration 2 is the recipe i mentioned earlier. I thought that perhaps hydration was the issue hence the increased water content, and reduced heating time for the carrageenan. This results in a smoother lighter mouth feel (you can tell its got a gelling agent). This is less sticky and more easy to handle, however the non exposed surfaces became wetter (i’m not sure if this is sweating, or that I have simply created an unstable suspension of carrageenan in egg white).

    I have found a more complex vegan recipe which appears to work, although to my eyes it seems under hydrated. Instead of using egg white it makes an artificial “fluff”:

    5T soy protein isolate 90% (available at many health food stores)
    2t Baking Powder
    1/4t guar gum
    3/4C cold water

    I suspect this works because of the soy protein and guar both enhancing the carrageenan. My current thought is to maybe add milk protein or condensed milk to the egg white as it is whipped since this should help the gel to stabilise?

  • Ume

    Sorry, i realised I missed out the full version of the vegan recipe:

    Fluff:
    5T soy protein isolate 90% (available at many health food stores)
    2t Baking Powder
    1/4t guar gum
    3/4C cold water

    Sugar Syrup
    1.5C raw sugar
    1C light corn syrup
    1/2C water
    1T Genutine Vegetarian Gelatin
    2t vanilla extract

    From http://veganmarshmallows.blogspot.com/

  • Dave A

    Ume,
    My guess is that the soy protein isolate is there as a whipping agent (similar to versa-whip), and the guar is their as a thickener and to provent water from leaching out of the carrageenan gel. It should function similarly to the LBG (but won’t modify the kappa texture as well).

  • laurie

    I was wondering if you could help me with a question regarding methylcellulose. I have tried using it in the past but unless the mix is extremely strongly flavoured, I can’t get past the smell of the methylcellulose. I tried Aki and Alex’s (Ideas In Food) idea of “steeping” plastic wrap in the mix, but it didn’t really work. Just wondering if there is anything else to try. Thanks.

  • davearnold

    Hi Laurie, could you tell me the percentage you are using and the type? Usually, methocel becomes really noticable in the 1% range depending on the recipe.

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>